Sciency Thoughts: Detecting debris disks around small nearby stars in old Hubble images.

Friday 11 December 2015

Detecting debris disks around small nearby stars in old Hubble images.

Debris disks are rings of dust, rock and icy material left surrounding stars after planet formation has occurred (unlike protoplanetary disks, which are present around very young stars only, and which are thought to be largely consumed by planetary formation). Our Solar System has two such debris disks, the Asteroid Belt and the Kuiper Belt, and in recent years improved telescope technology has allowed astronomers to detect debris disks around about 80 of other stars. Most of these disks have been detected only at infrared wavelengths; imaging disks at visual wavelengths enables astronomers to study the morphology and composition of such disks in far greater detail, enabling them to predict the presence of planets that cannot be directly detected and better understand planetary formation around other stars.

Almost all debris disks that have been discovered to date have been found around larger stars. There are several possible reasons for this. Firstly the majority of smaller stars are thought to form in dense star clusters (i.e. very close to other forming stars), which may prevent the formation of such disks. Smaller stars also tend to be less stable, prone to larger and more frequent stellar flares, tending to have higher stellar winds and stronger magnetic fields, all of which may potentially disrupt any debris disks, causing them to dissipate early in the history of such stellar systems. Alternatively such disks may actually be fairly common around smaller stars, but mostly be bellow the level of detectability due to the lower levels of heat and light emitted by smaller stars and the smaller size of the systems in general.

In a paper published on the arXiv database at Cornell University Library on 7 December 2015, a team of scientists led by Élodie Choquet of the Space Telescope Science Institute, describe four new debris disks discovered around small nearby stars Hubble Space Telescope images, the Archival Legacy Investigation of Circumstellar Environments (ALICE) project, which uses the Karhunen-Loeve Image Projection (KLIP) algorithm (better software) to analyse old images for debris disks that may not have previously been discovered.

The first disk described is around the M3.2 star (Red Dwarf Star with a mass less than 36% of that of our Sun) TWA 7. This star is about 34.5 parsecs (112.5 light years) away, and is associated with the TW Hydrae moving group, which is thought to be about 10 million years old, although one study has suggested that TWA 7 may be as young as 4 million years old. No emissions associated with accretion have been detected from this system, suggesting that any disk present would be an evolved debris disk rather than a protoplanetary disk with ongoing planetary formation. Infrared studies of the system with the Herschel Space Observatory have suggested that it might have two debris disks, one with a temperature of about 66 K at a distance of about 38 AU from the star (i.e. a debris disk with a temperature of 38 degrees centigrade above absolute zero which is 38 times as far from the star as the Earth is from the Sun) and one with a temperature of about 20 K at a distance of about 75 AU from the star. Choquet et al. were able to resolve a disk at a distance of 35 AU from the star. They could find no evidence of an outer disk, though they cannot rule out the existence of such a disk which may be to faint to detect.

Input unprocessed model of the debris disk around TWA 7. Choquet et al. (2015).

The second star examined was TWA 25, an M0.5 star (Red Dwarf Star with less that 50% of the mass of the Sun) 54 parsecs (176 light years) from out Solar System. TWA 25 is also associated with the TW Hydrae moving group, and is estimated to be about 13 million years old. The Herschal Space Observatory failed to find any evidence of a debris disk around TWA 25, though the Wide-field Infrared Survey Explorer (WISE) space telescope did record an excess of infrared at some wavelengths, which can be an indication of such a disk. Choquet et al. found an inclined disk around TWA 25, edge on from our perspective and about 78 AU from the star.

Input unprocessed model of the debris disk around TWA 25. Choquet et al. (2015).

The third star examined was HD 35650, a K6V star (Orange Dwarf Star with less than 80 of the mass of the Sun) roughly 18 parsecs (58.7 light years) from our Solar System. HD 35650 is thought to be associated with the AB Doradus moving group, which is thought to be between 50 and 200 million years old. The Spitzer Space Telescope detected an excess of infrared radiation at a wavelength of 70 μm, but not at 24 μm, which it is thought may indicate a debris disk with a temperature of 60K. Choquet et al. were able to detect an asymmetric disk at about 54 AU from the star, 70% brighter on the north side than the south. This disk appears to be compressed along its northwest axis, possibly due to the system moving into a denser area of interstellar medium.

Input unprocessed model of the debris disk around HD 35650. Choquet et al. (2015).

The final star looked at was HD 377, a G2V star (a stat with roughly the same mass as the Sun), approximately 39.1 parsecs (127.5 light years) from the Solar System. It this instance the Spitzer Space Telescope detected an infrared excess at 24 μm to 160 μm, the WISE space telescope at 22 μm and the James Clark Maxwell Telescope at 850 μm. This was thought likely to be indicative of two debris disks, one with a temperature of 240 K at a distance of 2.4 AU and one with a temperature of 57 K at 136.4 AU. Choquet et al. were able to detect a single debris disk, at a distance of 86 AU from the star.